Skip to Content

Original Irish Coffee

If you like this recipe, please share!

Warm up with a mug of original Irish coffee.

The weather has finally taken a turn for the colder. Each year when that happens, I try to warm up with coffee drinks.

I love my caramel coffee for such occasions but recently took to enjoying original Irish coffee. I do like bourbon and whiskey and the Irish version isn’t a stretch for me. Read on to find out the difference between the whiskeys.

What is the difference between Irish and American whiskey?

You may think it’s the process in which the whiskey is made, or distilled, but it’s not. The primary difference is their ingredients. Both are amber in color but Irish whiskey is made from barley while American whiskey is made from rye, wheat, or corn.

Irish whiskey can also be a blend of barley and malt. It’s always important to use quality ingredients and what you like. I’ve used a single grain Irish whiskey from Egan’s. It’s aged a minimum of 8 years in American oak barrels which also adds to the flavor. It’s slightly sweet with the nuance of warm spice. Irish whiskey, overall, gives a lighter and less sweet flavor than its American counterpart.

Warm up with a mug of original Irish coffee. #ourfamilytable

Why use brown sugar over white sugar?

Plain and simple. White sugar has no molasses in it. The process to make white sugar removes the molasses from the sugar cane. The process to make brown sugar puts it back. The result? A richer flavor for your coffee.

Did you know you can make brown sugar at home? Into one cup of white sugar mix one tablespoon of molasses. Stir until the sugar is completely coated. Use immediately or store in an airtight container.

So why is it Original Irish coffee?

Warm up with a mug of original Irish coffee. #ourfamilytable

Traditionally Irish coffee is served in a footed glass mug, which I do not have. I used the only glass mugs I have, which were my Mother’s.

But the original part really goes back to the use of whiskey and brown sugar as well as the fact it originated in Ireland. But the REAL secret is the cream. It’s lightly whisked then gently poured so it floats on top of the coffee.

It is impossible to use unwhipped cream. Trust me I tried. It just mixes right in. You want the slightly whipped cream to float because it’s part of the drinking experience.

The coffee comes through the cream as you sip. Interestingly, this concoction has only been around since 1942 when a young chef first served it in Limerick on a cold night.

Warm up with a mug of original Irish coffee.

 
2 mugs of Irish coffee with a bottle of Irish Whiskey in the background.

Original Irish Coffee

Yield: 1 serving
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes

Warm-up with a mug of original Irish coffee.

Ingredients

  • 6 ounces brewed black coffee
  • 2 teaspoons brown sugar, or to taste
  • 1 ½ ounces Irish Whiskey
  • 4 tablespoons heavy cream

Instructions

    1. You will need a mug, preferably a glass one. Fill the mug with very hot water and let stand for 2 minutes.
    2. Empty the water from the mug. Add the brown sugar, then add brewed coffee and stir.
    3. Stir in the Irish Whiskey.
    4. Place heavy cream in a mixing bowl and whisk until frothy, but pourable. You can also use an electric mixer.
    5. Hold a spoon upside down over the mug and carefully pour the cream over the spoon, allowing the cream to float on top of the coffee. Do not mix.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Did you make this recipe?

I'd love to hear about it! Please leave a comment below or share it on Pinterest!

Karen

Sunday 3rd of February 2019

Thanks for all of the information about Irish whiskey! This sounds delicious!

Anne Lawton

Sunday 3rd of February 2019

I've never tried to make Irish coffe, but this looks so good, I might just give it a try!

Cindy

Sunday 6th of January 2019

Thanks for the background on whiskey. I never knew the difference. How you add the cream is very cool too!

Jaida ~ Sweet Beginnings

Sunday 6th of January 2019

Now this is the kind of drink that will really warm you up!! Can't wait to try it!

Wendy Klik

Sunday 6th of January 2019

The perfect treat after a day of sledding, skating or skiing.

Skip to Recipe